In a desperate bid to stop Apple Inc.(NASDAQ:AAPL) from
getting its devices banned in the Netherlands, it has done the unthinkable -
actually run down its partner Google's Android operating system.
In a court in the Netherlands, where the two are
engaged in a battle over patent infringements, the Korean handset maker told
the court that Apple and Google's operating systems could not be compared as
Apple's was better than Android.
Samsung's claim came in response to Apple claiming
that the `touch' feature on its phones was violated by Google's Android
operating system - especially its version from Gingerbread onwards.
According to a report by Loek Essers, Apple had told
the court that Samsung should be barred from selling their Android devices in
Netherlands because they infringed on a multitouch patent that belonged to
Apple called ‘touch event model.’
Essers said in his report, "“Samsung has claimed
that the way Android's multitouch software works is not as good as Apple's, in
a bid to avoid a recall and ban on sales of its Android smartphones in a patent
dispute with Apple in the Netherlands.”
"“While Apple's technology is a "very nice
invention," the technique used in Android differs from the iOS solution, argued
Bas Berghuis van Woortman, one of Samsung's lawyers. Because the Android based
method is more hierarchical the system is more complex and therefore harder for
developers to use, he said. In addition, Apple devices disallow touch input in
sections of the screen on the OS level, while Android does that on the
application level, he said. Both are reasons Samsung's Android devices do not
infringe on the patent, he added.”
Funnily enough Apple was forced to disagree and
actually back Android. According to Essers - Apple disagrees. "They
suggest that they have a lesser solution, but that is simply not true,"
said Apple's lawyer Theo Blomme to judge Peter Blok, who presided over a team
of three judges, in a response to Samsung's claim. The technique used in Android
does solve a multiple input "conflict situation" and in that way the
Android software essentially does the same as Apple's, he said. It is also
possible to assign exclusivity to one particular "view" in Android,
and thus Samsung infringes on the patent, said Rutger Kleemans, Apple's other
lawyer in the courtroom.”
No comments:
Post a Comment