Some you win and some you lose.
About a couple of days after a Dutch court ruled that
Samsung had not violated an Apple Inc.(NASDAQ:AAPL) patent, the U.S.
International Trade Commission on Wednesday fund the Korean company in
violation of four Apple patents.
ITC's Judge Thomas Pender found that Samsung infringed
on three Apple utility patents and one design patent, meaning the Galaxy maker
might face an import ban if the six-member Commission agrees with the ruling in
a final determination, according to a report by Bloomberg.
Apple had filed a complaint with the ITC in July 2011,
a countersuit to a complaint by Samsung which had said that Apple's iPhones,
iPad and iPod had all violated patents related to wireless technologies.
Later Apple had made some changes to its allegations,
removing the one related to physical push buttons and 15 claims regarding
plug-in detections and multi-touch patents.
Apple and Samsung are fighting patent battles against
each other in about half a dozen courts across continents. At the core of these
battles is the fight for supremacy in the smartphones segment which has been
estimated as worth over $200 billion.
The Cupertino company has maintained that Samsung has
slavishly copied the designs of its iPhones and iPads and used them to build
its Galaxy range of smartphones, in which segment it is a market leader.
ITC's initial decision was scheduled to be handed down
last week. Like Judge Pender's ruling, the September decision must undergo a
final review by the Commission.
Only in the US does Apple get BS patents granted. Only in the US are these also somehow enforced.
ReplyDelete